History of Past Mystic Players Musicals & Plays 

1972The Mouse that Roared
1973Plaza Suite
1974Oliver
1975Flower Drum Song; George Washington Slept Here
1976Pageant Along the Mystic; Bull in a China Shop
1977Irene; Sondheim Revue; You Can’t Take It With You
1978Anything Goes; Kiss or Make Up
1979Take It Slow, Light & Lovely (Revue); Walking Happy
1980Soapy Murder Case; Rogers & Hart Revue; 350th Show; Mame
1981Plaza Suite; By George (Revue); Arsenic & Old Lace
1982Strictly Irving (Revue); Hooked on Broadway (Revue); Gypsy
1983The Man Who Came to Dinner; My Fair Lady
1984Never Too Late, Reprise (Rev.) (Some Enchanted Evening; Sound of Music
1985A Murder is Announced; Chicago; Born Yesterday
1986Come Back to The Five & Dime, Jimmy Dean; What the Heck (Dinner Theater); Music Man
1987Lovers and Other Strangers; What the Heck ’87 (Dinner Theater); Sweet Charity
1988Witness for the Prosecution; Cabaret
1989Brighton Beach Memoirs; Here We Go Again (Dinner theater); Pajama Game
1990The Butler Did It; I Wish (Dinner Theater); Funny Girl
1991Take 20 (Anniversary Show); Annie
1992Showboat; Rumors
1993The King and I; The Night of January 16th
1994Meet Me in St. Louis; LaCage Aux Folles
1995How Green Was My Brownie; South Pacific
1996Lost in Yonkers; Music Man; Oklahoma
1997Camelot
1998You Can't Take It With You; How To Succeed In Business (Without Really Trying); A Christmas Carol
1999Guys and Dolls; A Christmas Carol
2000Run For Your Wife; Little Shop of Horrors; A Christmas Carol
2001Oliver; Anything Goes; A Christmas Carol
2002Let's Do It Again! (Dinner Theater); Peter Pan; A Christmas Carol
200342nd Street; Holly Jolly Follies
2004Spring Chicken (Dinner Theater), Bye Bye Birdie, Holly Jolly Follies
2005Ten Little Indians, Peter Pan
2006
Arsenic & Old Lace (Dinner Theater)
2007
Cabaret, A Christmas Carol